Skip to main content Scroll Top

THE IMPERFECT LEADER

the-imperfect-leader

WHY ACKNOWLEDGING YOUR WEAKNESSES CAN BECOME
YOUR ORGANISATION’S ENGINE OF TRUE GROWTH.

What if the very qualities that made you successful as a leader become the ceiling that limits what your organization can become? I have been working with this question for many years – not as an abstract philosophical question, but as something I have wrestled with in a very practical sense every day.

When I started my own business, I was involved in almost everything. I helped shape the vision, worked with clients,made decisions, solved problems, and built the team. Partly because there was no one else to do it. But also because I enjoyed it. I liked being close to the action, being able to see what needed to happen and then making it happen. There is a real satisfaction in building something yourself, in seeing your ideas turn into reality, in knowing that your own contribution makes a difference. But then something shifted. The business grew. More people, more clients, more complexity.

Decisions multiplied. New challenges emerged that required capabilities I did not have, and attention I could no longer provide. I gradually realized that there were parts of the business that needed more than I could give them. Not because I lacked commitment, but because my strengths and my energy had limits. There were areas where my leadership was not up to what the organisation required.
At some point, I had to confront an uncomfortable possibility: my efforts to remain involved in everything might actually be holding the organization back.
This is not simply a dilemma every founder will face eventually. It is something every leader will encounter as their responsibilities grow and the challenges facing their organization become more complex. We are often promoted because of what we personally do well. We build our confidence around our expertise, our judgment, our ability to solve problems and deliver results. But as our responsibilities grow, the question changes. It is no longer simply whether we can lead well ourselves. It is whether we can build the collective leadership capabilities that allow the whole organization to perform.
And this requires a fundamentally different understanding of leadership.

The myth of the complete leader

We live in an era that still romanticizes the heroic individual. The visionary CEO. The decisive executive. The leader who sees what others miss, who acts when others hesitate, who somehow masters every dimension of organizational life.

The expectations we place on leaders have become almost comically expansive. They should be strategic and operational, visionary and pragmatic, empathetic and tough-minded, inspiring and analytical. They should understand technology, finance, people, markets, culture, and transformation. And ideally, they should excel at all of this simultaneously.

This is not a leadership aspiration – it is a recipe for cognitive and emotional overload.

Nearly two decades ago, Deborah Ancona and her colleagues challenged this myth in their Harvard Business Review article In Praise of the Incomplete Leader. Their central insight was that no individual can possess all the capabilities an organization needs. Leadership must increasingly be understood as something distributed across people with complementary strengths.

If this was true then, it is even more relevant today. Artificial intelligence is reshaping how we work, what organizations can achieve, and what capabilities they need. Technological possibilities are multiplying. Business models are evolving. Organizations must navigate greater interdependence, uncertainty, and change. The range of challenges leaders need to address is expanding faster than any individual’s ability to master them.

And yet we continue to develop, promote, and evaluate leaders as though individual completeness were both possible and desirable.

The problem is not simply that this creates an unrealistic burden on leaders. It creates a ceiling for their organizations. When leaders insist on personally covering areas where they are not particularly strong, those areas may never develop the capabilities they require. Decisions wait for someone who lacks the time or expertise to make them well. Talented people remain underutilized. Opportunities go unexplored. The leader becomes the bottleneck. The more complex the organization, the more costly this becomes.

The most successful leaders I have worked with are not those who come closest to the ideal of completeness. They are those who fully leverage their strengths, but also understand their incompleteness deeply enough to build something greater than themselves.

This is the maturity of the imperfect leader.

Imperfection is not an excuse for weak leadership

Before going any further, we need to make an important distinction.

Not every weakness deserves a development plan. But not every weakness can be delegated either.

Some limitations are deeply connected to our own psychological patterns. Our defensive behavior when being challenged. Our need to be right. Our difficulty trusting others. Our tendency to control, withdraw, or protect ourselves when we feel threatened. These are forms of psychological armor — protective patterns that may once have served us well, but now interfere with our capacity to lead.

We cannot simply ask someone else to compensate for them. A leader who consistently becomes defensive when challenged cannot appoint a colleague to handle disagreement and consider the problem solved. Someone who struggles to trust others cannot overcome that limitation merely by surrounding themselves with more capable people. These are aspects of ourselves that we need to develop. They require self-awareness, feedback, reflection, and the willingness to challenge patterns that may have become deeply ingrained.

But other limitations are different.

We may not be brilliant strategists, operational managers, inspiring communicators, financial strategists, or technical experts at the same time. Some capabilities are essential to our particular role and must be developed to

a sufficient level. But no leader needs to excel at everything their organization requires. There is no virtue in spending years trying to turn every weakness into a strength when someone else already possesses that strength in abundance.

Yet this does not mean that we can simply delegate away anything we find difficult. A leader remains responsible for understanding the essential requirements of their role. They need sufficient knowledge and judgment to recognize risks, ask informed questions, set meaningful expectations, and evaluate whether the organization is delivering what it needs to deliver.

A business leader does not have to be the strongest financial expert in the room. But they must understand the financial realities and consequences of their decisions. A leader responsible for a technology-driven transformation does not need to master every aspect of the technology. But they must understand enough to challenge assumptions, recognize the implications, and make responsible choices.

This is the distinction between distributing leadership and abandoning responsibility. We need to develop the capabilities and psychological maturity essential to our role, while deliberately bringing in others who can provide the complementary strengths the organization needs. And if we insist on leading an area ourselves despite lacking the necessary capabilities, we may be doing more than limiting our own effectiveness. We may be creating a ceiling for our organisation.

The mature leader needs the discernment to distinguish between the two. What must I learn to become a better leader, and where must I learn to share leadership with others?

This is not about accepting mediocrity. It is about taking responsibility for ensuring that the organization has the leadership it needs. And this responsibility rests on four mutually reinforcing foundations.

The four foundations of the imperfect leader

The imperfect leader is not someone who has given up on personal growth or accepted a smaller ambition. Quite the opposite. Imperfect leaders know what they bring. They understand their strengths, own their capabilities, and fully own the contribution they can make. They can be ambitious, courageous, decisive, and demanding. But they are also deeply aware of their limitations. They do not feel compelled to disguise them, compensate through an exaggerated display of confidence, or pretend to be strong where they are not.

At the heart of this is what I would call confident humility.

This distinction is captured beautifully in the words of Timothy Keller, who states that humility is not thinking less of yourself, but thinking of yourself less. Confident humility is not self-deprecation. Nor is it insecurity disguised as modesty. It is the ability to hold an honest picture of ourselves — our strengths and our limitations — without making our self-worth dependent on appearing capable of everything.

In our work, we have created a simple model of imperfect leadership, comprised of 4 dimensions. The model describes 4 components of imperfect leadership: self-awareness, understanding our own strengths and limitations while recognizing what the organization actually needs; vulnerability, having the courage to acknowledge our limitations openly rather than protecting an image of completeness; trust, allowing others to genuinely lead and giving their strengths the authority and space to make a difference; and values-based leadership, putting the purpose and success of the organization above our personal ego and taking responsibility for ensuring that the whole system can succeed.

Each matters on its own. But their real power emerges from how they reinforce one another.

1. Self-awareness: Seeing ourselves clearly
Everything begins with seeing ourselves clearly. Not the idealized version of who we would like to be, or the image of competence we want others to see. But the person we actually are, with our distinctive strengths and weaknesses.

What am I genuinely good at? Where do I bring something distinctive? What gives me energy, and where do others benefit most from having me in the room? Equally important: Where am I less effective? What do I consistently struggle with? What are my blind spots?

This requires more than introspection. We need honest feedback from others, because our own perception of ourselves is inevitably incomplete. But knowing ourselves is only half the picture. We also need to understand the system we are responsible for. What is my team asked to accomplish? What capabilities does our strategy require? What new challenges are emerging? Where are important parts of the business receiving insufficient attention or leadership? And where do my strengths meet those needs — and where do they not?

This connection between self-awareness and system-awareness is fundamental.

Self-awareness tells us who we are. System-awareness tells us what the organization needs. Responsibility begins when we bring these two truths together.

Without that connection, self-awareness can become little more than a sophisticated justification for remaining as we are. A leader may know perfectly well that operational discipline is not their strength. But simply acknowledging this does not absolve them of responsibility when poor execution holds the organization back. If the organization needs stronger operational leadership, someone must provide it.

The question is not whether I can personally cover every need. It is whether I am willing to confront the gap between what I bring and what the organization requires — and act on it. This is where self-awareness becomes a form of stewardship. We may not be responsible for every challenge our organization faces. But we are responsible for ensuring these challenges are being met. This requires us to see the limitations we bring.

2. Vulnerability: Having the courage to be seen as we are

Self-awareness alone is not enough. We can understand our limitations perfectly well and still spend enormous energy trying to hide them. This is where vulnerability comes in.

Vulnerability means being willing to let others see us, our strengths as well as our incompleteness. To acknowledge that we are not equally strong everywhere. To be open about where we need support, where we welcome challenge, and where someone else could make a greater contribution.

For leaders, this can be surprisingly difficult. We operate in cultures that frequently associate authority with certainty, competence with having answers, and leadership with being in control. Showing our limitations can therefore feel like exposing ourselves to judgment.

But vulnerability is not the opposite of confidence. It often requires confidence. A leader who feels secure in their own strengths can say, “This is not where I am at my best,” without feeling diminished.

And this has consequences beyond the individual leader. When leaders feel compelled to appear strong everywhere, others often become reluctant to challenge them or step into areas the leader seems determined to own. The leader’s need to appear complete can make the organization less able to draw on the capabilities it already has.

Vulnerability changes that dynamic. By acknowledging our limitations, we create permission for others to contribute. We signal that expertise matters more than hierarchy, and that recognizing what we cannot do is not a threat to our credibility. But vulnerability is not about displaying insecurity or transferring our responsibilities to others. It is about being honest enough to create the conditions for others to co-lead.

A limitation we hide becomes a constraint for everyone. A limitation we acknowledge becomes an invitation for others to co-lead.

3. Trust: Allowing others to genuinely lead

Here is where imperfect leadership becomes even more demanding. Recognizing and acknowledging our limitations is one thing. Genuinely allowing others to compensate for them is something else entirely.

We can hire talented people, praise their expertise, and speak eloquently about complementary strengths — yet still remain at the center of every important decision. There is a profound difference between saying, “You are better at this than I am,” and genuinely giving that person’s judgment real authority.

Trust means accepting that other people may approach things differently from us. That they may make decisions we would not have made, follow paths we would not have chosen, and achieve outcomes we might not have imagined. It means giving people not only responsibility, but also sufficient authority, freedom, and influence to make their strengths count. And it means resisting the temptation to reclaim control whenever something becomes important.

This is often where leaders struggle most. They want strong people around them, but they also want to retain the final say on almost everything. They welcome alternative perspectives, but struggle when those perspectives challenge their own. They delegate responsibilities, but not the authority to make consequential decisions. Their self-awareness may be genuine. Their willingness to relinquish control is not.

I recognize this tension from my own experience. When I brought in leaders to co-lead parts of my business, the challenge was not simply identifying the right people. It was genuinely letting go, without relinquishing accountability. Allowing their judgment to shape outcomes I cared deeply about. Tolerating the anxiety of not controlling everything. Trusting that their way of doing things, different from mine, might produce results I could not have achieved myself.

We do not truly compensate for our limitations simply by bringing strong people into the organization. We do so by allowing their strengths to shape what the organization becomes.

And there is another important consequence. When a leader constantly occupies the center, others can become dependent on their judgment, their decisions, their approval. Even highly capable people may gradually learn to hold back, because there is limited space for their own leadership. But when a leader can genuinely say, “This is where you are stronger than I am, and I want you to lead,” the relationship changes.

People are no longer simply supporting the leader. They are becoming leaders themselves. They have the opportunity to exercise judgment, take meaningful ownership, develop confidence, and discover capabilities that might otherwise have remained dormant.

This is one of the most powerful expressions of leadership maturity: the ability to make others stronger without needing to remain the strongest person in every room.

4. Values-based leadership: Taking responsibility for something greater than ourselves

The fourth foundation provides the deeper orientation for the other three.

Why should I acknowledge my limitations? Why should I make myself vulnerable in the first place? Why should I allow others to lead?

Ultimately, because leadership is not about me. It is about what we are trying to accomplish, the people we serve, the organization we are building, the legacy we will leave behind for others. This is where values-based leadership becomes a question of responsibility and stewardship. Our task as leaders is not to make ourselves indispensable. It is to ensure that the organization has what it needs to succeed. That includes the leadership capabilities we cannot personally provide.

Consider a leader who has built a successful business through vision, commercial judgment, and strong customer relationships. As the organization grows, however, operational complexity increases. Execution becomes inconsistent. Processes need to be strengthened, responsibilities clarified, and greater discipline established across the business.

The leader recognizes the problem. But operational management is not where they bring their greatest strengths. They face a choice. They can remain personally responsible for every important operational decision, compensating through greater effort and tighter control. Or they can empower a colleague with stronger operational capabilities to lead that part of the organization.

The second option may seem obvious. But it can be surprisingly difficult. It may mean giving up decisions they once made themselves. Accepting a different way of working. Allowing someone else to become the recognized authority in an important area of the business.

And perhaps confronting an uncomfortable question: Am I holding on because the organization needs me here, or because I feel the need to remain important here?

This is where values become real. A leader who puts the organization’s success above their personal need for control or recognition will make the decision that best serves the business, even when it challenges their own identity. They still define expectations. They still ensure alignment with the broader strategy. They remain accountable for the outcomes. But they create the conditions for someone else to lead better than they could themselves.

Stewardship means remaining accountable for the whole without needing to be personally in charge of every part.

When leaders are grounded in a clear sense of purpose and values, the need to prove their personal competence becomes less important. The question shifts from Am I the person who can do this? to What does the organization need, and who can best make it happen? From Who is right? to What is right? From How do I remain in control? to How do we create the conditions for success for others?

Values provide the anchor that allows leadership to be shared without losing direction or integrity. The imperfect leader fully owns their piece, but does not need to own every piece. And perhaps most importantly, they take responsibility for ensuring that all the pieces receive the leadership they need.

When the four foundations come together

The four foundations build on and reinforce one another.

Self-awareness helps us understand our own strengths and limitations, while system-awareness allows us to connect that understanding to what the organization truly needs. Vulnerability gives us the courage to acknowledge where

others may contribute more than we can. Trust enables us to go beyond acknowledging those strengths and genuinely give others the space and authority to lead. And values-based leadership provides the overarching purpose and sense of responsibility that holds everything together, ensuring that our decisions serve the success of the whole organization rather than our personal need for control.

Together, these four foundations turn the acceptance of our limitations into a different way of leading — one that allows us to build something greater than ourselves. It takes all four to turn the acceptance of our limitations into a different way of leading. And it takes deliberate organizational choices to make that way of leading real.

This is not an improvised response whenever we discover that we cannot handle something ourselves. It is a conscious and systematic approach to building a strong leadership team.

I learned this through my own experience. As my business grew, I recognized that certain areas were not among my strengths. If I continued trying to cover everything, those parts of the business would receive insufficient leadership. They would develop more slowly, execute less effectively, and ultimately constrain what the organization could become.

My limitations were becoming the organization’s limitations.

This was the insight that changed my approach: if everything depends on your personal capabilities, your weaknesses eventually become ceilings for everyone.

When I brought in complementary leaders, people whose strengths genuinely supplemented my own, two things happened. First, there was personal relief. I no longer had to carry

everything myself. I could focus more energy on the areas where I created the greatest value, knowing that other important parts of the business were in capable hands.

But the deeper impact was organizational. We could now develop capabilities I did not possess. We could pursue opportunities I would not have recognized. We could scale beyond the boundaries of what I could personally provide.

This is not about making leadership easier. It is about making organizational growth possible.

Every leader faces some version of this challenge. As complexity grows, the temptation is often to become more involved, to tighten control, to compensate for emerging gaps with greater personal effort. Sometimes that effort is necessary. But sometimes it reinforces precisely the bottleneck the organization needs to overcome.

Imperfect leadership provides a path towards understanding leadership not simply as the individual contribution of the leader in charge, but as a collective capability of the organization. Different people step forward where their strengths are most relevant. They challenge and complement one another, connect across boundaries, and take responsibility for outcomes beyond their individual territories.

A leadership team should not be a collection of individually complete leaders. It should be a complementary leadership system that is stronger than any of its members could be alone.

This does not eliminate individual accountability. Nor does it mean that every decision should be made collectively. It means that the greatest contribution a leader can make is not always to lead personally. Sometimes it is to create the conditions for someone else to lead better.

And this is perhaps the deepest promise of imperfect leadership. The leader who understands their own limitations does not necessarily become less powerful. They become capable of building a leadership system with far greater reach, intelligence, and adaptability than any single person could provide.

Imperfection, when combined with self-awareness, vulnerability, trust, and shared purpose, therefore paradoxically and beautifully becomes the starting point for true greatness.

As I reflect on my own journey, the moments that most expanded what we could accomplish were not always the moments when I developed a new competency or pushed harder.

They were the moments when I understood more clearly what I could contribute — and what I could not. When I invited people whose strengths complemented my own. And, perhaps most importantly, when I genuinely allowed them to lead.

You do not have to be everything your organization needs. But you do have to make sure your organization has everything it needs.

Questions worth sitting with

  • Where might my personal strengths, habits, or need for control have become a bottleneck for the people around me?
  • Which of my limitations are defensive patterns I need to work on myself — and which are capabilities that could be better provided by others?
  • What does my organization need today that I cannot, or should not, provide personally?
  • Whose strengths do I recognize and appreciate, but still fail to give real authority and space?
  • Where am I holding on to an area of responsibility because it serves my sense of identity rather than the needs of the organization?
  • If I were to design our leadership team entirely around what the organization needs next, what would I change?

One is too small a number to achieve greatness.

JOHN C. MAXWELL

Every project we shape is crafted with care and intention. Built through real collaboration, dialogue and a deep commitment to impact.
Start the conversation
info@atrain.com
+49 171 5528147​
curious to know more?
contact us
curious to know more?
contact us

Every project we shape is crafted with care and intention.
Built through real collaboration, dialogue and a deep commitment to impact.

Start the conversation
Privacy Preferences
When you visit our website, it may store information through your browser from specific services, usually in form of cookies. Here you can change your privacy preferences. Please note that blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience on our website and the services we offer.